Railroading Vancouver

Get the Environmental Impact Statment 

Contact: RailroadingVancouver@Gmail.com

Light rail costs too much, does too little.

What the Orange County Grand Jury found

Light rail and crime

· Light rail will have negligible impact on traffic congestion
· Light rail is expensive relative to other transit modes
· Light rail is inflexible
· Light rail cost and ridership forecasts ... biased in favor of light rail.
· Light rail will not spur development.
· Development along light rail corridors is spurred by tax subsidies, not light rail.
· Light rail will not improve commuter travel times, energy conservation and safety.
· Transit's share of land travel in the U.S. has dropped from approximately 6 % to less than 1 % since 1950.
· Virtually none of the pollution improvement is attributable to transit.
· Public transit is less fuel-efficient than the auto.
· Light rail is slower than the auto.
· The average auto work trip is about 19 minutes while the average transit work trip is 50 minutes.
· Light rail offers no advantages over express buses.
· Express buses . . . about 60 % faster than light rail's 16.2 miles per hour.
"The MAX has been a living nightmare for us,"  

Police: "I would not ride it at night -- and I'm armed all the time. There are massive fights, guns displayed, stabbings, people eing threatened and bullied."

MAX assault fuels worries of transit safety 6/14/08
Bystander wounded by gunfire at MAX station 5/2/08
Suspect arrested in bus stop shooting near Max 4/3/08
Knife attack on bus raises security concerns 
Area police say TriMet needs more officers
Knife fight on TriMet bus forces emergency action
TriMet: Three assaults in one week
Man Attacked On MAX Train

Sexual assault near MAX falls through cracks
Drug dealers could put an end to free rides ...
Woman sexually assaulted at Gresham MAX
MORE

Pamphlets to Read / Distribute (PDF files)

Additional Sources of Information 

The Look of Light Rail in Portland
Summary of MAX Fatalities
Transit Costs Three Times More than Driving
Europeans are Abandoning Transit Too  
How Density Causes Congestion
False Promises: Light Rail Reduces Congestion
Car vs Transit Energy
Light Rail Packet - Selected pages from the above
LATEST: Revised, version
Two Page Summary of the Orange County Grand Jury Report
Orange County Grand Jury Report with Added Summary Cover
A Comparative Analysis of Light Rail Systems in Six West Coast Cities

The Impact of Rail Transit on Transit Ridership
The Impact of Rail Transit on Urban Livability
Why do we support systems that almost never work?
THE PUBLIC COST OF URBAN TRANSPORTATION ALTERNATIVES.

PortlandFacts.com
Ortem.org

Cascade Policy Institute
Cato Institute
Washington Policy Center
The American Dream Coalition

Portland's Regional Government - Metro
Columbia River Crossing

Misc

From the Past

No more backing out of deals, Milwaukie told TriMet last week.

City officials question trust in TriMet
TriMet has pulled out of an agreement with the city of Milwaukie

TriMet and Metro hope to persuade the feds to contribute $840 million to the project. With the state’s $250 million contribution, that leaves local government agencies to come up with $160 million to $410 million.

TriMet to Milwaukie: Your light-rail share is $5 million

Joe Cortright :memo to local leaders on the financial risks (PDF, 51K)

Light Rail Travel Times (SLOW!)

1998 election: Trimte "shortened the ballot caption and eliminated from a summary statement claims that the line would reduce air pollution and traffic congestion, improve access to destinations along its route, reduce demand for new freeways and contribute to the vitality of neighborhood business districts." (Oregonian, Sept 2, 1998)

Opponents of the proposed south-north rail line have released traffic counts for the U.S. 26 Sunset corridor that show little apparent change in traffic volumes since the opening of the westside light-rail line. The counts at nine locations on the Sunset or along parallel routes show a traffic increase of slightly less than 1 percent since westside MAX opened Sept. 12. (Oregonian, Octr 7, 1998)

TRI-MET COUNT SHOWS WESTSIDE ATTRACTS 1,773 NEW RIDERS Train opponents put the number at 416 and say the cost of removing each commuter car works out to $2.6 million. The debate about ridership on westside light rail and its effect on traffic continued Wednesday, with Tri-Met saying it has attracted 1,773 new bus and rail riders in the westside corridor. (Oregonian, Oct 29, 1998)